2016 Offseason Analysis Part V: Defensive Line
The Seahawks have a significant gap on their interior line on early downs when they need to stop the run. The line is aging and they must decide whether to invest more in their veterans like Mebane and Rubin, or invest in younger options. Seattle likely needs to sign at least two defensive tackles before the draft.
Base Defensive Ends
Nickel Defensive Ends
Base Defensive Tackles
Nickel Defensive Tackles
3.4Position Rating
Reader Rating: (45 Votes)

This series will examine seven position groups on the Seahawks, reviewing their 2015 performance, and how the front office may make changes, including free agency or the draft. The final part of the series will propose a cumulative plan.

Part I: Quarterbacks
Part II: Offensive Line
Part III: Wide Receivers & Tight Ends
Part IV: Running Backs & Fullbacks
Part V: Defensive Line
Part VI: Linebackers
Part VII: Secondary
Part VIII: Summary & Recommendations

Article

State of the position: Defensive Line

 

The construction of the Seahawks defensive line deviates significantly from John Schneider’s typical recipe for roster construction. None of the starters were under the age of 29 last season. Only Brandon Mebane was drafted by Seattle, and not by this regime. They do have some young prospects like Jordan Hill and Frank Clark, but the bulk of this group relies on veteran performance and free agent acquisition.

No position group has challenged Schneider more in the draft than this one. Take a look at the defensive line draft choices since he arrived:

 

Year Position Round Player
2010 DE 4 E.J. Wilson
2010 DE 7 Dexter Davis
2011 DT 7 Pep Levingston
2012 DE 1 Bruce Irvin
2012 DT 4 Jaye Howard
2012 DE 7 Greg Scruggs
2013 DT 3 Jordan Hill
2013 DT 5 Jesse Williams
2013 DE 7 Ty Powell
2014 DE 4 Cassius Marsh
2014 DT 5 Jimmy Staten
2015 DE 2 Frank Clark
2015 DE 6 Obum Gwacham

 

The best results from those picks were Irvin, who was converted to linebacker, and Clark who still has yet to fully emerge. Jaye Howard is a very solid starting lineman, but he was cut in 2013 with the surplus of line talent the team had that year.

Hill has proven to be a useful player, but he failed to build on what had appeared to be a breakout end of 2014 when he finished with 5.5 sacks. He finished 2015 with a goose egg in the sack department and fought more injuries.

Marsh has looked fantastic in preseason and training camp the last two years, but has shown nothing as a pass rusher during the regular season. He is not a bust, given that he is an above average run defender on the line and a great special teams contributor. His lack of production in the pass rush, though, is disappointing.

That leaves a huge burden on veterans Michael Bennett and Cliff Avril to create pass pressure. They have been up to the task, but this team resembles the 2012 squad that leaned on Chris Clemons too much and had no replacement when he went down in the players.

The defense would suffer greatly if either Bennett or Avril went down, and Irvin very well may be moving on, so adding more to the pass rush is important this offseason.

 

Defensive Tackles

 

Both starters, Brandon Mebane and Ahtyba Rubin, are free agents. Both are on the downward slope of their physical primes, especially Mebane. There is precious little depth behind them. A.J. Francis is an exclusive rights free agent, which means he will be back with the team if they want him. He played well enough to earn a trip to camp, but not so well that the team can count on him to play significant snaps.

Mebane and Rubin did a solid job on the inside of the line, and were a big part of the team leading the NFL in rushing defense. Hill did some nice work in place of Mebane at times this year, but it would be asking a lot to expect him to step into the starter role.

 

Defensive Ends

Bennett and Avril are right up there with the best defensive end duos in the NFL. Bennett has the added advantage of being able to rush from the tackle spot inside as well as from the outside.

The team would be in serious trouble without either one of these two rushers. Clark showed promise, but has not been consistent enough to assume he is going to blossom next year.

A sleeper for next year could be Ryan Robinson, who was earning rave reviews during minicamp last year before suffering a season-ending achilles tear. There is an outside shot he could push for a spot in the rotation next year.

Marsh appears to be a good backup, without starter upside.

 

2016 Seahawks Free Agent Defensive Lineman:

  • DE Demarcus Dobbs
  • DT Brandon Mebane
  • DT Ahtyba Rubin
  • DT Jesse Williams (Exclusive Rights)
  • DT A.J. Francis (Exclusive Rights)

 

Seahawks Defensive Lineman Under Contract:

  • DE/DT Michael Bennett
  • DE Cliff Avril
  • DE Cassius Marsh
  • DE/DT Frank Clark
  • DT Jordan Hill
  • DE Ryan Robinson (Futures Contract)
  • DE Josh Shirley (Futures Contract)
  • DE DeAngelo Tyson (Futures Contract)
  • DT Justin Hamilton (Futures Contract)

 

Possible Free Agents To Consider

DEFENSIVE TACKLES

Ian Williams

Williams is likely going to command a hefty salary and sign on the first day of free agency. Schneider does not typically pay to play that early in the free agency game, but Williams has Pro Bowl potential. The only thing that has held him back from being the next dominant 49ers defensive lineman has been injury.
He played in every game this season, though, and was a rock on the inside. He is athletic, strong and young. The Seahawks could do a lot worse than to add a player like Williams to the middle of their line. Williams is not, however, a major disruptor. He will not add a lot of pass rush. That should keep his cost down a bit, as pass rush is always at a premium.

 

Brandon Thompson

Thompson has been a backup on the Bengals line for a few years. He had opportunities to start when Geno Atkins was injured, but got very little playing time this season.
The Bengals defensive line depth has been terrific for years, and Seattle has scooped up some of their backup players before, like Clinton McDonald. Thompson is a run stuffer who may fit more at 3-technique like Rubin where Seattle has been more willing to play taller tackles. Thompson is coming off an injury and has very little tape, which should keep his price down. Youth is always valued, but Thompson could be cheaper than Mebane or Rubin and possibly have more upside and longevity.
Jaye Howard
This one hurts. Howard was a Seahawks draft pick (4th round, 2012) who the team cut a year later when they one of the deepest defensive lines in NFL history. Howard is disruptive and stout. Seattle knows him well, but so does Atlanta coach Dan Quinn, who coached him in Florida and recommended him to the Seahawks. Don’t be surprised if Howard is a top target for Quinn and the Falcons woeful defense. Still, he deserves mention here as he is a very good young interior lineman who would be an upgrade at 3-technique.
Sealver Siliga (Restricted Free Agent)
Another painful loss, although not quite as tough as Howard. Siliga was acquired when the Seahawks traded John Moffitt to Denver. He was cut just like Howard in 2013 in the face of overwhelming veteran competition along the defensive line.
He was scooped up by the Patriots, and became a key part of their improved run defense. His development was a big part of what allowed New England to move on from Vince Wilfork. He would be a terrific option to replace Mebane at nose tackle, and should not break the bank. The Patriots are likely to want him back, but they have a mixed history of tendering restricted free agents, and their limited cap space may preclude their ability to put a high tender on Siliga.

DEFENSIVE ENDS

Malik Jackson

Malik Jackson is a monster. Von Miller and DeMarcus Ware are credited for creating the Broncos relentless pass rush, but Jackson plays a major role in wreaking havoc, often in the middle of the line.

Jackson is perfect for the Seahawks scheme, as he can play both inside and outside. He will definitely be a first day free agent and command big bucks, so the likelihood that Seattle will stick their nose in there is low. He is the type of player who is definitely worth checking out to see if there is any way to bring him aboard.

Olivier Vernon

Vernon is going to be another popular target. He probably goes off the board on day one. Young, and with upside, Vernon had a monster second half of the season. Of his 7.5 sacks, 5.5 came in the final eight games. He benefitted from being opposite Cameron Wake and having Ndamakong Suh in the middle to draw protection priority away, but the production can’t be ignored.

Should the market value Irvin similarly to Vernon, the Seahawks may prefer what Vernon brings as a true defensive end. As well as Avril has played, he turns 30 this year, as does Bennett. Adding a young edge rusher makes a lot of sense.

 

Jarvis Jenkins

Jenkins has been a late bloomer. Drafted by the Redskins in the second round of the 2011 draft, he totalled just two sacks in his first three seasons. He became one of the more productive interior pass rushers with the Bears this year, gathering 4.0 sacks.

His upside is lower, but the price should be as well. Jenkins is more of a 3-technique defensive tackle for the Seahawks than an end, but he could play the Bennett role at 5-technique as well. Seattle has Jordan Hill and Clark who are young and under contract, but Jenkins could earn a look if the top-shelf players

 

Jason Jones

Jason Jones is an interesting one. He is on the older side, and will not go off the board right away. He is also a proven pass rusher who can be disruptive off the edge and on the interior.
He played for the Seahawks a few seasons back, and was extremely effective when healthy. He has managed to stay on the field the past two seasons in Detroit and racked up 4.5 and 5.0 sacks and bunch of pressures. This is the type of lower-priced veteran who could be a great addition deep in free agency.
Chris Long
Long is newly available after being waived by the Rams. He is 30 years old, and has struggled through injury and decreasing performance the last two years. He may be worth a look if he’s available for cheap.
Quinton Coples
Coples is still just 25, and is an intriguing option for Pete Carroll and crew to mold. He should be available at a good price, and I’d generally prefer they go for young players with upside like Coples than older veteran like Long.

 

8 Responses

  1. Nathan_12thMan

    It is critical for us to have our upcoming ’16 DT draft pick be at least good, impactful and productive. Would be nice to have Hill start showing up, heck maybe even a sack or two from Marsh, and of course the development of Frank Clark is key.

    It is also very important to make the right decision on who to re-sign (my vote is on Rubin over Mebane), and to find more talent. Whether that means we get a FA DT like we did Clinton McDonald and Ahtyba Rubin or finding a UDFA DT in this year’s class who is being overlooked by the draft process and deep DT class which allows us to potentially find a talented DT in undrafted free agency. Think the DT version of Rawls, or Doug, or even Kearse. A quality impactful player who can fill a role and produce.

  2. Raymond

    Seattle seems to sign a Vet DT every year and good good production out of them while limiting their snaps so they are fresh. I would bring Rubin back. The other Vet DT I would target is Haloti Ngata.

    He had a down year as Suhs replacement, but when healthy he is still a mountain of a man who can move the pocket. If he can be had for around 3 or 3.5M as a rotation DT I would pursue it.

    He can stuff the run and probably get 4-5 sacks in 500-600 snaps

  3. HD

    Seattle I think will spend their top 4 picks on lineman…2 offense…2 defense. Schneider does have a knack of finding rotational guys as lower cost free agents. I think they sign Rubin, draft a DT and DE. As far as free agent…Silga or Nagata.at DT..I think both Jacksonville and Oakland are going to get the best shot at the expensive free agents with their huge amounts of cap dollars; and their coaching staffs. Look for Atlanta to try to grab one…possibly Irvin or Howard.
    Jones, Coples, Thompson are interesting possiblities.

    • Raymond

      Trouble with the draft and DT is the draft is deep with quality DTs but not pass rushing DTs.

      • HD

        There’s not a whole lot of Shorts or Donald’s around…Jackson is out of Seattle’s price range…Hill showed promise in later in 2014 with pressure up the middle…not in 2015…McDonald was good at that in 13…Maybe there is someone as a backup that has potential on someones roster.

  4. Just Me

    I think Frank Clark played well above average last year, and would have been a starter on most teams. He’s already playing at 7 to 8 on a scale of 0 to 10. He’d have seen a lot more playing time, except for the fact that both Avril and Bennett are consistently playing at an 8 or 9 level. So we’re great at DE already, and really need to focus only on DT.

  5. hawkman54

    They definitely need help inside , It looks like they better hope they get a couple of great draft picks this year . Probably resign Rhubin along with that . They need somebody that can also ceate some pressure up the middle , which they didn’t get much of last year .

  6. Cam

    Think Jordan Hill is better than given credit for here IF he can stay fit, which I’ll grant appears to be a big if atm. I agree with all here though that given the depth of DTs in the draft this year it would be a major shock if JS & PC didn’t invest in a new young tyro there.
    I also expect to see Clark given a lot more work next season & hope he can step up to the plate.

", source:"wp" });