Browner Hate Is Misplaced

Media members flooded the Virginia Mason Athletic Center. They had come from far and wide to see one man run on the field. Terrell Owen had signed with the Seahawks, causing quite the stir. The man was a physical specimen. At 6’3″ and 225 pounds, he was accustomed to pushing around smaller opponents. He would meet his match on this day. After mugging for the cameras and running by players in contact-free drills, Owens lined up for his first 1-v-1 route. Across from him stood 6’4 220 pound Brandon Browner. The ball was snapped and Owens took a jab step right before trying to cut the outside. Browner stood patiently and let Owens come to him. His arm extended, Browner knocked Owens off balance before adding his second hand and driving the future Hall of Famer into the ground and onto his back. Notice was served. You are not bigger than us. You are not stronger than us. We are the bullies.

Always Controversial

Since the moment Browner joined the Seahawks in 2011, the fanbase has been divided about his contributions. His second game as a starter saw him get beat often by the Steelers. A large number of fans and media were ready to show him the door right there and then. He stabilized and became one of the most impactful players on an emerging defense, earning a trip to the Pro Bowl. His signature moment would be his 94 yard interception return for a touchdown against Eli Manning in New York when the Giants were threatening to take the lead late in the fourth quarter.

Still, he was penalized often. His size and physical nature have always been a double-edged sword. There are plays he can make that no other corner in football is capable of, like the way he dominated Jermaine Kearse on that game-deciding interception in the Super Bowl. Then there are the agonizing moments watching him try to get his hands on quicker receivers, often resulting in holding or illegal contact penalties. He will annihilate a receiver like this:



Then he will late-hit an offensive lineman away from the play, costing his team 15 yards and a first down. Detractors like to point to his penchant for penalties, his struggles against double moves, and his vulnerability against quicker receivers. They see a player who is not good enough to warrant all the bad. Most teams agree with that sentiment. I do not, and apparently neither do the Seahawks.

Expert operator required

They say the tool is only as effective as the person using it. Very few coaches in the NFL know how to utilize Browner. In fact, the list may be limited to two of the best defensive minds the game has ever seen in Pete Carroll and Bill Belichick.

Browner is a ball-peen hammer, and everyone wearing an opposing uniform is a nail. He is an intimidator. He is a mauler. He is a badass.

Where many fans see him suplexing a receiver and getting a 15-yard penalty as a boneheaded play, teammates see a message being sent and opponents feel it. So many people think of Kam Chancellor as the enforcing member of the Legion of Boom. Browner was every bit as tough. The team lost some of that edge when he left.

Breno Giacomini was another player who drew more than his share of penalties for extracurricular play, but he was as tough as a $5 steak. The Seahawks have lost a lot of their bullies over the past three years. Now they have a couple of them back in Browner and Chris Clemons.

Nobody should expect either player to come in and be their best self. They are older and have always had limits to their game. Carroll collects unique parts and puts them in position to succeed.

Browner was terrible last year. Nobody should argue that. There are a few key differences between Seattle and New Orleans: Earl Thomas, Kam Chancellor, Richard Sherman, Kris Richard and Carroll. When you have Sherman on one side, the defensive staff has the luxury of designing coverages to greatly assist the other corner. Browner was rarely asked to operate without safety help in Seattle. Carroll and Richard narrow his job description down to something that matches his skill set.

Cary Williams required safety help last year, but he brought nothing to the table. He was not physical. He was not a good cover corner. He was not a good press corner. Everyone has weaknesses. Williams lacked strengths. Browner will never lack strength.

This is not to say he is the perfect corner. Far from it. No matter who the Seahawks surround him with or how the coaches scheme to help him, Browner will get beat. He will be among the league leaders in penalties. He will give opponents first downs on stupid holding penalties away from the play. He also has a knack for creating turnovers and winning games. His value is complex, but that doesn’t mean it should be dismissed.

Ask the Patriots how they felt about him during his time there. He was the talk of camp when he arrived, and his style of play helped define an eventual champion.

“One of the things about Browner is he not only exerts his physicality, but he’s found a way to get into the heads of opposing receivers. There were a number of instances yesterday where after the play was over, or after the series was over, Broncos players were very frustrated and engaged in some verbal sparring, with Brandon Browner front and center right there for the Patriots. This guy brings an edge and we saw some of it in preseason — he even got into it once with a Patriots assistant coach because he was giving Kenbrell Thompkins such a hard time with his physical play during one training camp drill.

“I think his attitude and his play on the field has really carried over into this defense. I hate to use the term because I think it’s overplayed in sports, but they’re playing with a lot of swagger in that secondary and I think Brandon Browner has been a big part of that.” – Bob Socci, Patriots Play-by-Play Voice

Nothing is guaranteed

Fans who are nervous that Browner has nothing left in the tank, or just think he stinks, are spending energy needlessly. Seattle will open camp with anywhere from seven to nine players who could compete for the corner spot opposite Sherman, and that’s before the draft. Tharold Simon is still the guy I want to win the competition. He has the best combination of size, speed, youth, and coverage ability of the group. His big question mark is durability.

Jeremy Lane was signed to a nice deal, but too many assume that was to be the starter on the outside. Lane was most often utilized as a nickel corner, with DeShawn Shead playing outside. Both will have a chance to compete outside. Mohammed Seisay showed promise in his brief stint before injury. Tye Smith was a redshirt rookie last year who should be ready for a chance to compete for more playing time. Carroll has complimented George Farmer, who spent time on the practice squad. Stanley Jean-Baptiste is 6’3″ and 218 pounds, and has a chance to emerge as a camp surprise.

Browner will have to prove he is worthy of a spot on this roster. Seattle will not be afraid to play without him, as they have done the past two seasons. Should he earn his way back onto this team, though, Seahawks fans should celebrate the addition. This team needs to get tougher. The defense needs to create more turnovers. Browner can help.

Founder, Editor & Lead Writer
  1. Yea, Browner will have to earn his way past a group as described here, so if he is able to earn a spot that’s good. If not, that may speak well of another. Win-win.

  2. I’m glad to see him back and competing for time as a Seahawk again. If he doesn’t make the team its because everyone else is better- and I’m okay with that. He’s beloved by his LOB teammates and others. He’s a total team guy who has his own style. I have a hard time with any hate towards a player who helped the Seahawks win a superbowl and helped develop our championship culture. I will always cheer him as a Seahawk and as a former player once he returns for alumni appearances. He may have a ring w/ the Patriots against the Seahawks, but he’s a Hawk and he knows it. I hope this works out- I see no downside.

  3. I LOVE Browner. Ford Tough and then some!

    However, he’s never been fast and when he left a least I was relieved to know that Thomas wouldn’t have to play as his wingman on EVERY passing play.

    Perhaps now we’ll need two Thomas’ covering the grass behind him. BUT – I still LOVE the guy…

    1. Short area quickness has never been his strong suit, but straight line speed? I’ve seen Browder track down some of the fastest relievers in the league. Also, don’t forget about how he can contribute on special teams. I’ve seen him plant three players on their butts on a single punt return

  4. Any thoughts of using him as the third safety in big nickel packages? Seems like a logical role. He can match up against TE’s which, as everyone knows, was a weakness last year. They can still match him up at corner based as needed.

    1. Ron, this is EXACTLY what I thought when I heard BB signed. With the growing importance of the TE and Seahawks lack of success last year (comparative to previous years), it might be the perfect niche for BB. He is big and his physicality can match that of opposing tight ends. Perhaps that would free up KJ to bring additional pressure on the QB?

  5. Is Browner a possible conversion prospect to SS? He might be competing for Cam’s job.

  6. Best way to tell how good/bad defensive backs are is to watch who offenses pick on- especially on 3rd down. When Browner played with Seattle, he was always the guy thrown at.

  7. I love the thought of potentially having him match up against the TEs, especially seeing that we seem to chronically struggle against them now. There are some tough ones on the 2016 schedule, here’s a taste of what’s to come:

    MIA – Jordan Cameron
    LA – Lance Kendricks
    ATL – Jacob Tamme
    NO – Coby Fleener
    AZ – Jermaine Gresham
    BUF – Charles Clay
    NE – Gronk
    PHI – Brent Celek
    TB – Austin Seferian-Jenkins
    GB – Richard Rogers

  8. I have wondered how he would be as a strong safety, i the role that Chancellor has. He could be a good back up to Kam.

  9. I don’t see how Seattle loses on this one. BB was a valuable player when here; if he can bring a reasonable facsimile of that to downs best suited to him, they’re ahead of the game.

    Brock Huard’s hope is that BB can suit up for every game and be ready when needed. That sounds reasonable.

Comments are closed.